Comparison
Complete Vanity Sets vs Buying Separately — The Real Math
The biggest question in bathroom vanity shopping: is it better to buy everything as a set, or hunt for the best deal on each component? Here's the real math, with Canadian prices.
Last updated: April 2026. All prices in Canadian dollars.
7
Modern Vanity
0
Tie
1
Buying Components Separately
| Feature | Modern Vanity | Buying Components Separately | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cabinet (36") | Included | $300-$800 (Home Depot, Wayfair, IKEA) | |
| Quartz Countertop (36") | Included | $200-$500 (custom cut or prefab) | |
| Undermount Sink | Included | $80-$200 | |
| Backsplash | Included (quartz) | $50-$150 (tile or stone) | |
| Hardware (handles/knobs) | Included | $20-$60 | |
| Total Estimated Cost | $749 (fixed) | $650-$1,710 (variable) | |
| Matching Guarantee | Everything designed to match | You hope the pieces work together | |
| Customization | 3 colours, standard configs | Unlimited — any style, any material |
Choose Modern Vanity If…
Anyone who wants a guaranteed-matching, all-inclusive vanity at a predictable price. Eliminates the risk of parts not fitting, mismatched aesthetics, or budget creep.
Choose Buying Components Separately If…
Renovators with very specific style requirements (vessel sink, custom stone, unique finishes) or who already have some components and only need to replace others.
Our Verdict
For a clean, modern bathroom with quartz countertop and undermount sink, buying a complete set saves $100-$600+ compared to piecing together equivalent quality. The hidden cost of buying separately isn't just money — it's time spent matching components, the risk of parts not fitting, and multiple delivery logistics.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do I save with a complete vanity set?
Based on Canadian retail pricing (2026), a complete 36" vanity set from Modern Vanity at $749 saves approximately $100-$600 compared to buying equivalent-quality components separately (cabinet + quartz countertop + sink + backsplash + hardware).
What if I only need a cabinet replacement?
If your existing countertop and sink are fine, buying separately makes more sense. Complete sets are best when you're doing a full vanity swap or new installation.
Can I use my own countertop with a Modern Vanity cabinet?
Our sets are sold as complete packages only. The cabinet, countertop, and sink are designed to fit together precisely. We don't sell individual components.
More Comparisons
Ready to See Our Vanities?
Complete sets from $399. Everything included. Free GTA pickup.
Shop All Vanities