Comparison
Complete Vanity Sets vs Buying Separately — The Real Math
It seems like you'd save money building your vanity from individual components. In practice, the math almost never works out — you spend more, wait longer, and hope everything fits together. Here's the real breakdown.
Last updated: April 2026. All prices in Canadian dollars.
7
Modern Vanity
0
Tie
1
Buying Components Separately
| Feature | Modern Vanity | Buying Components Separately | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cabinet (36") | Included | $300-$800 (Home Depot, Wayfair, IKEA) | |
| Quartz Countertop (36") | Included | $200-$500 (custom cut or prefab — adds weeks) | |
| Undermount Sink | Included | $80-$200 | |
| Backsplash | Included (quartz) | $50-$150 (tile or stone — plus installation) | |
| Hardware (handles/knobs) | Included | $20-$60 | |
| Total Estimated Cost | $749 (fixed, known) | $650-$1,710 (variable — usually $1,000+) | |
| Compatibility Risk | Zero — everything engineered to fit | You own the problem if parts don't match | |
| Customization | 3 colours, standard configurations | Unlimited — any style, any material |
✓ Choose Modern Vanity If…
Anyone doing a standard bathroom renovation who wants a guaranteed-matching, all-inclusive vanity at a predictable price. Eliminates compatibility risk, budget creep, and weeks of sourcing.
When Buying Components Separately might make sense:
Only makes sense if you have a custom size requirement (non-standard width), want a specific premium natural stone, or you're a contractor with wholesale trade pricing.
Our Verdict
For a standard bathroom renovation, buying a complete set saves $100-$600+ compared to piecing together equivalent quality — and eliminates the hidden costs of time, coordination, and compatibility risk. The only reason to buy separately is if you have a genuinely custom requirement that no complete set can meet. For everyone else, a complete set is the smarter choice.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do I save with a complete vanity set?
Based on Canadian retail pricing (2026), a complete 36" vanity set from Modern Vanity at $749 saves approximately $100-$600 compared to buying equivalent-quality components separately (cabinet + quartz countertop + sink + backsplash + hardware). The savings are even larger when you factor in your time.
What if I only need a cabinet replacement?
If your existing countertop and sink are fine, buying a cabinet separately makes more sense. Complete sets are best when you're doing a full vanity swap or new installation — which is the case for most bathroom renovations.
Can I use my own countertop with a Modern Vanity cabinet?
Our sets are sold as complete packages only. The cabinet, countertop, and sink are engineered to fit together precisely — that's how we guarantee compatibility and keep costs low. We don't sell individual components.
More Comparisons
Ready to See Our Vanities?
Complete sets from $499. Everything included. Free GTA pickup.
Shop All Vanities