Comparison
Modern Vanity vs Home Depot — Complete Sets vs Piecing Together
Home Depot is the go-to for many renovators, but their vanity buying experience is designed around selling individual components. Here's how a complete Modern Vanity set compares to the Home Depot approach.
Last updated: April 2026. All prices in Canadian dollars.
3
Modern Vanity
2
Tie
3
Home Depot
| Feature | Modern Vanity | Home Depot | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buying Experience | One product = everything included | Buy cabinet, countertop, sink, hardware separately | |
| 36" Vanity Total Cost | $749 (quartz top, sink, backsplash, hardware) | $800-$1,400+ (cabinet ~$400-800 + quartz top ~$200-400 + sink ~$80-150) | |
| Countertop | Engineered quartz (included) | Cultured marble (cheap models) or quartz ($200-400 extra) | |
| In-Store Viewing | Markham showroom (limited models on display) | Most stores have floor models to view | |
| Selection | 33 products, 3 colours, 6 sizes | Hundreds of options, many brands | |
| Delivery | Free pickup, $140-$200 delivery (GTA) | Free shipping on orders $35+ (some exclusions) | |
| Return Policy | Final sale (damage claims accepted) | 90-day returns | |
| Installation Support | DIY guide included, WhatsApp support | Installation services available ($$$) |
Choose Modern Vanity If…
Buyers who want a premium-look vanity at a fair price without the hassle of matching components. Ideal if you want quartz countertop and don't need 50 colour options.
Choose Home Depot If…
Buyers who want to see products in person, need specific styles/brands, or want the security of Home Depot's return policy. Also better if you need installation services.
Our Verdict
Modern Vanity wins on total value and convenience. A comparable Home Depot setup (cabinet + quartz top + undermount sink + backsplash + hardware) costs $200-$600 more. But Home Depot wins on selection, return policy, and in-store availability. If you know you want a clean White, Grey, or Blue vanity with quartz, Modern Vanity saves you money and time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Modern Vanity better quality than Home Depot?
For comparable price points, Modern Vanity includes a quartz countertop where Home Depot equivalents typically use cultured marble. Cabinet construction (HDF) is similar to Home Depot's mid-range options.
Can I return a Modern Vanity like I can at Home Depot?
No — Modern Vanity products are final sale. We accept damage claims with photo evidence. Home Depot offers a 90-day return window, which is a genuine advantage if you're unsure.
More Comparisons
Ready to See Our Vanities?
Complete sets from $399. Everything included. Free GTA pickup.
Shop All Vanities